Jun 11, 2021
Dartmouth apologizes and drops charges against all 17 medical students accused of cheating during online exams following a massive backlash against a ‘flawed investigation’
This news has been received from: dailymail.co.uk
All trademarks, copyrights, videos, photos and logos are owned by respective news sources. News stories, videos and live streams are from trusted sources.
The Dean of Dartmouth's Geisel School of Medicine apologised to the 17 students that were charged with cheating in March in an email to the school community.
'I have apologized to the students for what they have been through and believe dismissal of the charges is the best path forward,' Geisel Dean Duane Compton wrote in the email sent on Wednesday.
Dartmouth charged the 17 students with cheating earlier this year based on a review of some of their online activity on Canvas - a learning management system widely-used among universities.
The school claimed that the students - during a closed book examination being held online - accessed other web-based course material at the same time.
But backlash came from students and alumni, and from the wider academic community, who argued that the data being used by Dartmouth was being misinterpreted, and did not show that the students had cheated.
The Dean of Dartmouth's Geisel School of Medicine has apologised to the 17 students that were charged with cheating in March in an email to the school community
Using Canvas, professors can post resources and assignments for their students, who in turn can submit their work through the system online and remotely.
The school quickly dropped cases against seven of the students after at least two argued that administrators had mistaken automated Canvas activity for human cheating.
Now, Dartmouth has dropped the allegations against the remaining ten students, who before were facing expulsion, suspension, course failures and misconduct marks against their academic records that could have ended their medical careers.RELATED ARTICLES
- Dartmouth professor is cleared of sexually harassing... Dartmouth's medical school accuses 17 students of cheating...
The school has now offered 10 of the students who received sanctions in April an opportunity to appeal the decision.
The decision to dismiss the charges came after an investigation that lasted months, that initially resulted in a Geisel committee recommending three students should be expelled and others receive lesser punishments.
The students argued that the medical school was misinterpreting the data about their usage of Canvas, which the university was using to track student activity without their knowledge.
Geisel Dean Duane Compton (pictured) apologised to the medical students in an email on Wednesday over the erroneous cheating accusations that could have seen them suspended
This was unusual, as Canvas was not designed to be a forensic tool, according to the New York Times, whose own review found the student's Canvas activity could automatically generate data - even when not being used.
With the clash turning the Ivy League school into a battleground over increasing school and student surveillance during the Covid pandemic, Dartmouth's practices were condemned by some of the school's alumni, along with some of its faculty and other medical students - leading to protests on campus.
In a statement on Thursday, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) wrote: 'It was a process in which Dartmouth appeared to gravely misunderstand, or willfully ignore, the highly complicated data it used as the basis of its accusations against the students.'
Dartmouth's use of Canvas raised questions, technology experts have said, and while some students could have cheated, it would be challenging for school administrates to be able to tell the difference between cheating and non-cheating.
That was down to the kind of Canvas data snapshots that Dartmouth used, according to the New York Times.
Some of the accused students said that Dartmouth had limited their ability to defend themselves, being given a 48-hour time limit to respond the charges.
A screenshot of a Canvas dashboard. Students denied accessing the remote learning platform to cheat during exams, and have now been cleared of the charges
They were also not given full access to the data logs for their exams, were advised to plead guilty despite maintaining their innocence, and in some cases given just two minutes to make their case in online hearings, according to six of the students and The Times, after reviewing documents.
But in an interview in April, Dr. Compton said that the used by the school school to identify possible cheating were fair and valid, and argued that administrators had provided the students with all the evidence the accusations were based on.
He also denied the claim that those who said they had not cheated were encouraged to plead guilty.
With the clash turning the Ivy League school into a battleground over increasing school and student surveillance during the Covid pandemic, Dartmouth's practices were condemned by some of the school's alumni, along with some of its faculty and other medical students - leading to protests on campus
But in his email on Wednesday, he took a less combative tone.
'As we look to the future, we must ensure fairness in our honor code review process, especially in an academic environment that includes more remote learning,' the dean wrote. 'We will learn from this and we will do better.'
In FIRE's statement, Foundation Program Officer Alex Morey said the school needed to introduce policies in order to protect its student's rights.
'Dartmouth's fresh commitment to 'rebuilding trust' among the students it unfairly accused in this case should start with promising a fair process to all future students who may find themselves facing a similar misconduct allegation,' Morey said.
'When it comes to trust, due process provides it: Giving everyone involved confidence that when a school reaches a result in a misconduct investigation, it's a fair one.'Read more:
- Dartmouth Medical School Drops Cheating Case Against Students - The New York Times
News Source: dailymail.co.uk
Tags: topics index some of the school’s the school’s school’s alumni dartmouth’s practices alumni geisel the new york times that the students apologised remote learning the students that could argued to plead guilty students after medical school the charges students the students the decision the decision against the medical has dropped
Man, 35, dies following ‘altercation involving a group of men’ as cops launch murder probe in Buckinghamshire
DETECTIVES have launched a murder investigation after a man died following an “altercation” with a group of men.
Officers were called to reports of a fight in Burnham, Buckinghamshire, at around 1.10pm today.2Thames Valley Police have launched a murder investigationCredit: Google Maps
Emergency services discovered the 35-year-old man who had collapsed on Wyndham Crescent in the leafy village.
He was pronounced dead at the scene, and his next of kin have been informed.
Officers are appealing for witnesses to come forward, and no arrests have been made.
A Thames Valley Police spokesman said: “Officers were called today at about 1.10pm following reports of an altercation involving a group of men in Wyndham Crescent.
“Shortly after this, the victim, a 35-year-old man collapsed. Officers and paramedics attended the scene and performed CPR on the man but he was later sadly pronounced dead. His next of kin has been informed.
“No arrests have yet been made, and officers are appealing to members of the public to come forward if they have any information which could help.”Most read in NewsLatest'BODIES IN THE AIR'Video shows Florida Pride crash as mayor slammed for 'terrorist' claims'IN CAR WITH STRANGER'US student found dead in Russia after cryptic 'abduction' textWarningSIDEWALK 'SHOOTER'Cops picture man wanted over NYC shooting just INCHES from two kidsLatestSTORM CRASHEight girls on trip for abused kids killed with dad & baby in 15-vehicle wreck'BRAINWASHED'Trump fan charged in Capitol riots pushes conspiracy theory victims are ALIVE'HEAVIER BLEEDING'4k women reporting period problems after Covid jab monitored by watchdog
Senior investigating officer, Detective Chief Inspector Stuart Blaik, of the Thames Valley Police Major Crime Unit, said: “We are in the very early stages of this investigation, and we are working to establish the circumstances of exactly what has happened.
“Therefore, details at this stage are fairly limited. However, if you were in the area at the time and witnessed this altercation, or if you have any other details which you think could be useful to us, please get in touch.
“You can do this by calling 101 and quoting reference number 43210270867, or you can call the independent charity Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111. Alternatively, you can make a report online.
“I appreciate that this incident could cause a great deal of concern in the community, but I would like to take this opportunity to reassure people that firstly we have launched a thorough investigation to identify those responsible, and secondly that we do not believe there is any threat to the wider public."2Emergency services discovered the 35-year-old man who had collapsed on Wyndham CrescentCredit: Google Maps